Thanks Mike F
|
|
|||
|
|
Harry Potter vs. Twilight449 comments to Harry Potter vs. Twilight |
||
|
Copyright © 2012 Bits Of Wisdom - All Rights Reserved |
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
Harry Potter vs. Twilight
Thanks Mike F 449 comments to Harry Potter vs. Twilight |
||
|
Copyright © 2012 Bits Of Wisdom - All Rights Reserved |
|||
P.S I LOVE LOVE LOVE HARRY POTTER i have read it bout fifty times! but i also do LOVE LOVE LOVE TWILIGHT- haven’t read it as many times as Harry Potter but still brilliant! they both are
i thnk HP is bttr dan twilight. i read both de books so here is what i thnk abt twilight and HP
twilight – really very exciting
new moon – really boring
eclipse – excitng bt nt as de first
breaking dawn – yuck, srsly its de most stupidest book i hve read in my entiRE LIFE!! she marries a vampire & den has a baby ( her delivery done by edward & jacob (double yuck)). den jacob falls in love with renesme. when evrythng bcms fine entr volturi…4 an entire month dey prepar demselve 4 an attack & in de end de attack doesn’t happen. srsly i thnk meyer has gone nuts
now HP
socceror’s stone- exciting
chamber of secrets – more exciting
azkaban – excitng bt nt as first
goblet – rlly vry excitng with voldemort rising
order – really very boring
half blood – rlly rlly exciting …concept of horcrux u go back 2 second book & remember thngs
deathly hallows- de plot is superb. HP & his frnds try 2 destroy horcrux with no clu…in his desperation he tries 2 rmmbrs thngs & so do we. its full of adventure with lots of plots. in dis book u actuall pity voldemort. in bw de one way line bw snape & lilly is absolutely AMAZING. dis book connects wid almost all de other books & so yearn 2 read de other books once more..de ending is dramatic with voldemort dying. this is perfect.
the end line” the scar has not pained me for nineteen years. all was well” is beautiful. for a moment i cudnt believe it dat it has finished. it has left a void which cannot be fille by any book.
i hve read both HP and twilight many times though twilight is entertaing can u actuall read it more dan twice??thrice??
You can read?
Lol. But I luvvv hp and agree with Anju, 100%. Go hp!!!!! Oh and anju u make a great point.
You beat me to that question.
How can you claim you’ve read two entire book series with such a questionable grammar?
UMMMMMM HELLO? Harry potter is one-hundred billion times better than Twilight.I’m not even going to go on. This is a stupid argument. If you watch Twilight, you should see a doctor. And as for you ‘Harry Potter fans’ who’ve only seen the movies.. I’ll invite you to the kitchen behind the pear painting with Winky and Peeves. Oh? Who are they? Get out of my life, filthy muggles.
U listen to me hermione granger, ur parents r muggles. Watch it.
You’ve obviously not taken an notice of the main point of the book?
Harry potter > Twilight
Griffindor FTW!
I support Gryffindor and Hufflepuff. Who said that the badgers aren’t as outstanding as the other houses? The badgers have their share of glory, also.
I don’t think you can even compare the two books. J.K. Rowling spent FIVE YEARS working on the plot of Harry Potter, and when you dig deeper you find that so much effort went into the writing of the books. The golden snitch that Dumbledore gave Harry said, ‘I open at the close’, J.K. Rowling started writing the books in 1998, the same year the final battle of Hogwarts took place (the close). She opened the series at the close. That’s just a small part of all the detail that actually went into the writing of the book. Even the names of the characters are detailed- Sirius Black’s name came from the star called Sirius: Orion’s dog, and Sirius turned into a dog; Remus Lupin’s name is derived from the Latin word ‘lupus’, which means wolf, and Lupin was a werewolf.
There is just so much thought and effort that went into the Harry Potter series, Rowling planned the entire plot of all seven books before she had even started writing the first one. Then when you look at the Twilight series, there are no twists, carefully thought out plots or anything. Stephanie Meyer could’ve just been making up the plot as she wrote. I really don’t mean to critisize her, I just want to point out all the hard work that went into the Harry Potter series. It’s amazingly that even adults are avid fans of Harry Potter even though it’s meant to be a children’s series.
Okay, I know I’m not really addressing the question, but I just want people to stop saying that Twilight books are more amazing than Harry Potter. The Twilight books were good, but Harry Potter is just on a whole different level. Speaking from the perspective of a 14 year old female who has read both series, I can honestly say that there is no comparing the two as they are both so different and meant for completely different audiences. On another note- Harry Potter is amazing and Rowling is my queen <3 Anyone who has not read the series is seriously missing out, because the books basically changed my life. Can you say the same about Twilight?
Blimey, I never noticed that, ‘I open at tue close’ bit! That is amazing, you must be so smart!
Well I saw the first twilight movie and found it good but it didn’t attracted me to watch the series while on the other hand when I watched Harry Potter-The real epic(at least for me)…I was dying to watch the whole series.Now I have watched the full HP series more than twice each and still with the first twilight not interested to watch the sequels…I guess the topic love doesn’t fascinates me as much as adventure does.
I’ve read and watched both series, and the Twilight movies just keep on getting worse. I actually liked the first movie, the second was boring and so was the third, and I didn’t even go to the cinema to see the fourth one. I was bored so I just rented it when it came out on DVD. Book by book, also, the series grow really bad and boring.
CRAZY HARRY POTTER FAN…………EMMA>KRISTEN….HARRY>EDWARD….HARRY POTTER>TWILIGHT
Check out bioswithpassion on tumblur!!!!! I love Harry potter!!!!!!!!!!!!
Harry potter ( as Stephen king said), is about facing fears and conquering evil with love always in your heart. Twilight is about a love triangle but that’s all that it will ever be. It has no interesting plot or message that you will learn about in the end… Harry potter FTW!!!! I will always love Harry pottet and it is my childhood andlifestile… Go, Go, Gryffindor!!!!!!!!!!
Barely a love triangle……if it even has a plot.
Still…. People…. Wow…. Uhh…. All I can say is…. HARRY POTTER 4EVR! Also Avpm(A very potter musical) To all who havent seen A Very Potter Musical…. Its on Youtube…. You all serously need to watch it.
I LOVE HARRY POTTER! I think that Twilight SUCKS!
How can you compare something as amazing as Harry Potter to something like Twilight? I’ve read both the books and (shamefully) there was once a time when I loved Twilight and Hated Harry Potter.
Now the tables have really turned and I hate Twilight and Love HP. Twilight has a very weak overall plot (Being with Edward) and the books don’t seem to connect. There are several plot holes, Under- developed characters and Bella is such a boring Mary- Sue that it’s not funny. Harry Potter has an overall plot (defeating Voldemort) that continues into smaller plots (eg: Romione). It teaches you lessons (Death is but the next greatest adventure… Love is the most powerful thing in this world) It’s imaginative (Hello? A whole new world?) Harry Potter has Better romance (Lupin/Tonks, Snape/Lily , Ron/Hermione) and JK Rowling told a better love story in one chapter than Meyer did in 4 books. If I could change it, I would make my 7 year old self realise how AMAZING HP is and Have read the books before DH was realised. ( I knew exactly what was going to happen before I saw the movies and read the books… Thanks Mum) and I would’ve left that stupid twilight book in the dusty store bookshelf. Where it belonged.
Okay, I’m not gonna bash or anything, because if I want to be really honest with myself, I have a guilty fondness for Twilight. Now don’t hate me on this, because I totally agree Twilight doesn’t come near Harry Potter, not by a long shot. But it all depends on what you’re looking for. If those girls want to giggle and swoon over dark, brooding vampires, for goodness sakes let them! I mean, Twilight is a typical romance story of the supernatural. Harry Potter is an epic fantasy adventure. How do you expect them to compare? No matter how they are written (and even I admit that Meyer’s main character is an annoying Mary-Sue) they both created history in each genre they are created for. Yes, Harry Potter has and always will be inspiration for all to come (including me) but Twilight has spawned several supernatural-romance stories because of its creation, you can’t deny that.
So yeah, HP kicks ass, but don’t go around saying Twilight sucks just because some kids think sparkling vampires are better than teenage wizards. For all you know, your harsh comments just made twelve-year-old tweens cry their hearts out worldwide.
REASONS WHY I LIKE THE HP BLACKS BETTER THEN THE TWILIGHT BLACKS (my fav black is regulus)
1 Narcissa lied to voldy when he asked if harry was dead
2 when Bellatrix’s kills sirius she runs around screaming i killed sirius black
3 Andromeda is nmpyadora’s mother (i love tonks )
4 Regulus died trying to destroy one of voldy’s horocruxs
5 Sirius went against his family at a young age thats hard to do
thats why i like hp blacks better than twilight blacks
ok you twihards really need to get it together, ive had enough
Fellow Potterheads, are you still talking to annoying Twilight fans? No matter how many times we tell them that Twilight is CRAP and PLOT LACKING they still won’t get it! So why waste time talking to unimaginative losers when you could be re-watching the films, re-reading the books, learning all the spells and potions off by heart and other Harry Potter related stuff that you could do!
Nox
I love h
Ow Harry potter is so complicated, yet clearly laid out, so that people can understand it, and still have to use their brain to think about the plot
OMG, how can anyone even IMAGINE a world where TWILIGHT is as AMAZINGLY SPECTACULAR as HARRY POTTER????? I just…I mean…I can’t even.
HARRY POTTER FTW!!!!!
SHUT UP you stupid Harry potter fans because twilight is 1 million times better (no exaggeration there). Seriously arent vampires and werewolves wayyyy more interesting than stupid wizards and witchcraft and other shit like that? Twilight involves more interesting characters than Harry potter, vampires, werewolves and an awesome normal girl who falls in love with a vampire and later becomes one in breaking dawn. Twilight has a better story plot too. Twilight is WAY WAY WAY better than crappy Harry potter.
give reasons please. Do I even need to say this to every twilight fan?
LMFAO i cant belive you think a whiny teenage girl who goes into a zombie like state no not depression she was way past depression who trys to kill herself over a boy is better than the boy who lived and come on me and you both know twilight is the one with the crappy plot and you twitards are really annoying cause you all say that twilight is the best thing out there and its not and there are children novels out there that are better than twilight also a good book to read if anyone is looking for one is fablehaven i know its a childrens book but its really good
First off, you really should work on your reasons. The only thing I understood is that someone finds werewolves and vampires more interesting than wizards. Okay. Understandable. I’m sure many people have this opinion, but it isn’t something you say on a debate. I can say ‘I prefer ice cream than chocolate’ but if I don’t say why it’s like I never said it. Secondly -and this is a huge mistake- Twilight DOESN’T involve more characters than Harry Potter. That’s a fact, not an opinion. If you only look at that page in the end of Half Blood Prince where it says who came to Dumbledore’s funeral, only the people mentioned there are more than all the Twilight characters. Thirdly, Bella is so now awesome, and I’ll tell you why. She acts like a tool, like someone who doesn’t have thoughts and opinions on their own, one that only does as they’re told by their boyfriends. And I’m surprised at this. Isn’t it mentioned in Twilight that it was more like Bella taking care of Renee than vice versa? -I may be wrong, but, Bella acts everything but mature in the series. If that’s how Stephanie Meyer imagines the perfect girl then… what can I say? My last objection is about the plot. Maybe someone believes Twilight has a plot, that’s understandable as well, but you can’t say it has more than Harry Potter, otherwise J. K. Rowling would have been an idiot to spend years on its plot, while Stephanie Meyer saw it in a dream. I’ve seen many dreams but I don’t start writing a book about them, even though it would be an interesting one. Who knows, maybe Stephanie Meyer found it poetic or something.
Anyway, that’s it from me for now. I hope my comments interest you.
You obviously haven’t read Harry Potter AT ALL. There was so much thought into the plot of Harry Potter, she went back to the days of the old testament and created characters and family histories. Twilight is complex enough to have been written in crayon.
First of all Harry Potter is the best invention since sliced bread.
I used to love Twilight. I was 13 and it was just what i was looking for at the time, but HP has always been my favourite. I don’t understand how people can argue that Twilight has a better plot, because it doesn’t have one. In HP1 there are bits of information that become extremely relevant in HP7. JKR’s work is AMAZING. HP is interesting and exciting, it makes us laugh and cry, it is about love, adventure, friendship, loyalty, death, life and standing up for what you believe in. It is way better than Twilight.
For those who say Twilight is all about love, it is not,its just lust. It doesn’t make sense that people want to read about a whiny, depressed, self absorbed, boring teenage girl who is prepared to die for a guy she has JUST met. It cannot be compared to to a story of true love, with brilliantly written characters and an epic battle between good and evil.
LONG LIVE HARRY POTTER!!!
ME
I completely agree with you …….. though I dont think that a slice of bread has importance such as harry potter ….. lets just say ….. HP is the best medicine for retards who like twilight !! CHEERS!!!
true that
Well well well Lord of Twilight eh ?? I guess you are as geeky as all of them. Twilight is sooo not 1 million times better that hp …. are u out of ur mind ??? JKR is such a great writer!!! I mean she has thought out the whole story …. for instance on HP2 , harry goes into borgin and burkes and sees the vanishing cabinet which has great revelance in Hp6 ,, in twilight all I can see that the books are kept in series by a crappy , selfless (so called)girl , a love ridden werewolf and a gay glittery vampire ….. well excuse me for calling him gay but come on …. he doesnt have sex cuz its tii dangerous …
ALL HP FANS RULE !!!!!! LONG LIVE HARRY POTTER !!! COMMENT !!!!!
Hey … I just wanted to ask one thing : There is one plothole in Hp7 that I am not being able to get over… in HP5 well they were in yhe ministry in the end u know …. im wondering why harry does not steal some time turners and get sirius back ???? I’m only wondering and dont worry …. im no twilight fan …
the time turners were destroyed in the ministry of magic before the order arrived, so they couldnt
Ok one more plothole …. in HP6….. dumbledore tells harry that if u have magical parents , you can do magic at home and it will not be detected by the ministry …. i mean atleast ron should be allowed to do magic atleast in the burrow i mean …… please explain
Just one last plothole… in HP7 when harry ron and hermione overhear dirk cresswell and the others , ted tonks just stands infront of the lake and does accio salmon…. why couldnt hermione do that instead of cooking inedible mushrooms which made ron queazy and eventually ron went away ?????
Omg just saw commercial 4 breaking dawn, about to die.
My dream is to become eleven years old again and find a letter from Hogwarts saying I m am selected to get admission in the greatest school of witchcraft and wizardry ,the same year Harry gets admission…wow!I would replace Hermoine there if could or become friend of Harry and help him in every problem…love the series…the books…the movies…and all!
well Felix felicis (Liquid Luck) u should drink some of it too c’mon no offense but read the books u will get answers to every question if u haven’t read them yet…And Ron can use magic in his burrow as everything there is already magical and he,george and fred took their dad’s car to rescue harry in chamber of secrets remember…(they will never get caught there dad is in ministry)(just saying)BUT SERIOUSLY READ THE BOOKS
*their instead of there in the second last line
When I watched part of twilight, I was like ,” Eww, I dont wanna watch anymore.” I ♥3 Harry Potter!!! Way better then Twilight
thank god you’ve got som taste sister !!!
Well I’ve been reading the whole argument that started July 17 and I have to say twihearts you have been owned.
.
But I have to say this. The first time twilight came out. I forgot all about HP. Stephenie meyer just put one twist in the so-called-obvious-plot. She made the bad guys the good guys.
But the fact is that there wasn’t anything else to it. Stephenie has just tried to stretch and stretch it into a whole series. And the end result was that : me being a twiheart at the start ended up saying WTF:X. If she had just finished the story line in twilight maybe it would have been a better story. I mean that there was no place for werewolves in the novels and volturi are the most lame excuse for villains.
So I’m a potter maniac through and through. I love it so much that I’ve watched the movie so many times that I can tell the scene and dialogue just by hearing the music.
When I finished the books I thought that what an amazing and intelligent person rowling is who has made me a whole new world of which I could think about when I’m sad and depressed and if I ever get to make a wish. It will be to make hogwarts real.
And all of my fellow HP fans will also get acceptance letters.
hmmm.. twilight is awesome..
i can say that HP is good.. but it didn’t capture my attention at all. there is one part i didnt understand . really! my reaction was “is that all? what happened? whats the sense??”.. it is good in terms of actions and all that.. but for me.. love is all that matters.. twilight showed how love is willing to give.. how love is sacrificial.. boom!! though.. we can’t compare the two of them.. they have there own genre’s.. STOP COMPARING!pls!
Do you belong to the human clan?????
CAN’T certain people BE fascinated by such thing as HP without insulting other creations???
there are both good!!!! IF PEOPLE COULD JUST APPRECIATE DIFFERENCES..
HARRY POTTER FANS ARE ALL GOOD IN INSULTING. blablabla! CAN’T YOU SHOW ANY RESPECT FOR THE 2 BOOKs?? see?they are not created to be compared..!
I love Harry Potter its so fantastic but I hate Twilight its so boring.In Harry Potter they play about Wizards,frinds and ather this its so beautiful.
I say it becaus my sister Emma Watson play in the films mand I really like it!
Bye your Nana!!!!
(Sorry I wirte ather but I will wriding other).
In Twilight they play about one only one ,,thing” and thats boring.I love films with many ,,things”
and Harry Potter is also my favorit film.
If people really have common sense and know the value of friendship,bravery and love I am sure they will keep their eyes and ears off Twilight.I believe I have those factors and so do millions of Harry Potter fans.
Those who think getting pregnent at 18 and falling in love with your lover’s daughter is cool — ROT IN HELL!!!!!!!!!!
PS: Stephanie Meyer must be dragged and shot in the streets full of HP lovers
HP is Better than Twilight
#PotterHeads from Philippines!
Harry Potter has values throughout the series and is an intelligent series. Twilight is a self-insert Mary-Sue who is weak just so she can please her boyfriend. Harry Potter has so much thought put into it, whereas twilight was written three months after a dream. It took J.K. Rowling fifteen years, as a single working mum as well, to come up with not just the characters, but the entire laws, world, buildings and curriculum. Twilight is set in America (as is almost everything else) in a boring little town with a boring little life. The most exciting thing that happens in it is when James almost eats Bella (shame he didn’t. Could have been better that way).
Harry Potter has changed millions of lives around the world and teaches good values – loyalty, bravery, wit and the need to survive. Twilight shows people the boring life of a boring girl who falls in love with a sparkling, vegetarian vampire.
I’m sorry, but I’m definitely going Harry Potter.
The Prince’s Tale, chapter thirty four I think in the Deathly Hallows (I don’t have the book with me so I can’t be sure what chapter it is), tells a better love story with a guy who was rejected than Twilight did in four books. Twilight is soppy American crap (no offence to Americans) and Harry Potter is a mixture of genres that will be remembered as a legendary series.
Harry Potter is more Interesting to Watch ! Twilight is Boring. No Offense
)
Oh. My, HP is million times better than Twilight. HARRY POTTER For the Win. Respect my Opinion!!
Okay man. Lemme settle this.
Harry potter has an awesome adventure game (One of the best in my opinion). And it makes you relive the whole harry potter world.
Whereas twilight also has one of the greatest games of all time……..
Oh wait. Twilight doesn’t have a game that doesn’t involve glittering dildos.
Robert pattinson is so LAME that even before he was in twi-crap, he was in hp and DIED! remember “Kill the Spare!” direct quote from voldemort. and COME ON!!!!! Twilight is crap. i could wipe me arse with the contents of that rag. It’s the worst thing ever!!!! Harry Potter is the best series. I agree with Sir Stephen King when he said that. It’s true! Harry potter made me confront my fears of spiders(so cute<3) and found my inner strength. Twilight…Bella…she is a plain jane, with no redeeming qualities, who falls into a fatalistic relationship with a sparkle-fag vampire that spawned four books and a movie franchise…and has a kid, married and prego at 18…yeah, thats an amazing story…for an idiot. I learned so much from hp. from twilight…i learned not to read anything by sm. wait, scratch that. the only remotely good part of twilight was the short second life of bree tanner. she had more substance than bella!!! if sm ended that crap story at the beginning, it MIGHT'VE been good. but nope, she had to draw it out, making it so RIDDIKULUS! i swear, if twilight was a boggart, i would've banished it already. and i know the hp-heads here agree wholeheartedly:)