Thanks Mike F
|
|
|||
Harry Potter vs. Twilight301 comments to Harry Potter vs. Twilight |
|||
|
Copyright © 2012 Bits Of Wisdom - All Rights Reserved |
|||
|
|
|||
Harry Potter vs. Twilight
Thanks Mike F 301 comments to Harry Potter vs. Twilight |
|||
|
Copyright © 2012 Bits Of Wisdom - All Rights Reserved |
|||
I forgot to say a couple of things-
1: I did notice most of those things were copied (when I searched for Black Family in google and got an image of Jacob)
2: I totally agree about Rob, he is so ugly in Twilight!
3: Renesme & Jacob = YUCK
5: They are animagasus, COPIED
6: I’ve read both series and movies and HP just kills Twi.
7: They can’t be compared!!!
8: I agree with a lot of other things you guys said too…
J.K. Rowling obviously worked really hard to create words with real meanings! Voldemort literally means “escape from death”!! ironic, right? That’s only one example! the names of the different alleys include Knockturn Alley(nocternally) and Diagon Alley(diagonally. All the charms have latin roots of some sort. http://www.angelfire.com/stars2/fawkesfire/Names.html
here’s the link where i got those examples from ^^~!
The twilight book names…. sure, the names have meanings that make sense(edward means “noble guardian”, etc) but the names arent anything unique or special.
OMG!!!!!!!!!!HP is totally the best…. i mean seriously who in their right mind would like twilight.. and stephanie meyer you totally copied sirius black (who is completely amazing
btw… fawkes is sooo coool
Twilight is the worst book EVER!!!!!!!!!! go hp and lotr
Trying to prove that Harry Potter is way better then twilight is impossible. The twihards are too stupid to know any better! Let’s all just be happy in the knowledge that Harry Potter is awesome, and twilight is a book you buy in an foriegn airport cause you have like thirty seconds before your plane leaves and it’s the first one you could find in English before you go on a plane for like 5 hours.
And then you end up throwing it at a terrorist and even then you know, that; goddammit, Harry Potter would’ve knocked that sucker out and SAVED THE FRICKIN’ PLANE. But I digress.
I know that Twilight is way better than Harry Potter! Harry Potter is okay, but Twilight is way better, I love Twilight. Twilight is amazing! But people have their own opinions, this is just mine.
hwhat!!! twilight is just another teen book MARY! and harry potter has a deep filled story. the language and words they use in twilight is so amature.
das ist ja total scheiße was hast du dir den dabei ausgedacht behindert oder so
1029384756luser
I am back
, like I should have said last time I see the few twilight fans tht are commenting are only saying stuff like ‘oh I just love twilight.’, ‘twilightis the best.’ is you acually are a twihard then why dont you name some reasons why you think twilight is better than harry potter.
Here is a few resons why hp is better than twilight:-
1. Giiny vs. Bella – harry broke-up with ginny for her safety she goes and helps try to re-start the da back-up with neville and luna, tries to steal the sword of griffyndor for harry nd stayes loyal to harry. edward broke-up with bella for her safety she tries to hook up with jacob, curls up in a ball, goes comatose (soz 4 spelling) for months and throws herself off a cliff.
2. sm totaly copied Jo, Sirius black- jacob black, werewolves!, bellatrix-bella!
and many more…(dont say Jo copied sm cuz’ hp was out well before twilight!)
3. The name origins- has anyone noticed the names in hp actully mean something for example voldemort, spelt ‘vol de mort’ in french means ‘flight of death’in english and thats what he is doing isnt it running away from death + sirius black, SIRIUS is the dog star and blck is the coulour of dog he transforms into, so his name means dog, black/black dog there are lots more but can’t be bothered listing them.
Annie, this comment is truly amazing! It’s nice to know there are intelligent people in the world who understand a good book when they read it
I love how you compare Bella with Ginny. Of course, Ginny is much much braver, doesn’t cry (which I think Harry loves, look at Cho!) and performs a wicked Bat-Bogey Hex, which helps in Order of the Phoenix.
Bella stays in a seat for months, crying her heart out, and just generally behaving like a sulky, moody teenager. God, when I watched New Moon, I was crying with impatience, screaming, ‘Get on with your life, girl!’ People stared.
However, when I watched Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2, I was crying so much. Neville’s speech was so moving. It was beautiful.
Also, if you don’t like Twilight, watch Vampires Suck. And read Nightlight, New Moan and Breaking Yawn. I started reading New Moan in English, and I had to stifle my laughs; my friends were just looking at me so weirdly. But when I showed them New Moan, they couldn’t help laughing, too.
hp is so pointless like wizards of waverly place is better when twilight actualy has a plot
What?! What?! What?! No it doesnt! It promotes domestic violence and patheticness! Where is the plot in that? Where is the meaning? People have written essays on why hp is better and all ypu can think of is ‘twilight has a plot’ no it doesnt.
you mean a boy born to save the world is pointless. how would you like to have to through away nearly every thing that means something to you. to be thrust into a war like that because this powerful evil guy picked you before you could even talk!
wizards of waverly place? never heard of it, sounds kinda boring.
Powerful dialogue, Annie.
HARRY POTTER IS NOT POINTLESS ARE YOU CRAZY AND WIZARDS OF WAVERLY PLACE HAS A BETTER PLOT THEN TWILIGHT AND THAT SAYS A LOT SINCE ITS A DISNEY SHOW
Firstly, what?
Harry Poter is pointless?
Have you actually opened a book up and read it from cover to cover?
Because you’re comment seems to lack the knowledge that you would know if you read Harry Potter.
Every book is written for a reason.
Harry Potter was written about a boy named Harry who is orphaned by his parents due to a man named Voldemort who after is destroyed as well. The boy is then rescued and taken to his Aunt’s and Uncle’s home to live with them and their son, Dudley. Throughout the books revelations and secrets are revealed to Harry and the life he has to love become’s more and more clearer. The seventh book’s climax has Harry die willingly at the hands of Lord Voldemort. After a talk with the school’s late headmaster Dumbledore, who has an Memorable quote ‘do not pity the dead, Harry. Pity the living, and above all, those who live without love’
Harry Potter theme’s are endless and timeless, and in years to come where we don’t walk the earth anymore, Harry Potter will still be studied. The theme of why fight? Is a huge theme that throughout every book is explained again and again.
Love conquers evil is another theme. When Harry’s mother gave Voldemort the choice to kill her instead, he did yet unknowingly gave Harry Potter an advantage, Love. Love it what kept Harry alive and striving all those years in his battle against Voldemort and lurking evil. The love of his friends, the Weasleys, the Order of the Phoenix, Sirius Black, Ginny Weasley and countless others who believed in him is what kept him going until the very end. When Harry finds the resurrection stone in the Golden Snitch, he see’s his parents, James and Lily Potter, Sirius Black and Remus Lupin. When Harry asks ‘You’ll stay with me?’ and They reply ‘ until the very end’.
While you may argue that the contrast between Harry Potter and Twilight are similar in the words of Stephen King the big picture of twilight simply is about getting a boyfriend.
Oh. My. God. Are you being serious? *splutters* You actually think Twilight has a … a plot?!
Well, if you think vampire boyfriends who glitter in the sun (!) and stupid clumsy girls are interesting, then I seriously suggest a trip to the hospital. Or mental asylum.
I don’t really get Bella. I don’t understand how she can trip on an entirely smooth surface. I mean – what is with that? I’m sometimes clumsy but even I can walk right.
Harry Potter – a beautiful story woven with pure passion and intensity.
Twilight – umm … oh yeah, a poor (!), clumsy teenager who has nothing better to do than have sex, um, risk her life and become a vampire.
Harry saves the entire wizarding world, and even starts to banish anti-werewolf, anti-giant (Grawp) and other anti stereotypey stuff.
And … what does your Bella do? Sits around, moping and whining. In New Moon, I was just begging, literally, ‘GET A LIFE, YOU BEEPING BEEP!’ Something along those lines.
Stephen King is so right, don’t you think, HP fans?
the only plot twilight has JAZILL is that a girl moves school falls in love with a vampire (who sparkles!) , gets dumped by the vamp (honestly if this were happening to me i would be jumping for joy just now.), tries to go out with a werewolve (who doesn’t look or act like a werewolve.) fails at that,curls up in a ball, jumps off clift, gets back together with the vamp, marries him and has baby! seriously you call that a plot!
i mean how did they actully manage to fit that into four films! it hardy fits one!
I like how all Pro twilight have maybe one incorrect reason for twilight being better. While pro-HP have multiple reasons with supporting bits from the book. Thus I come to the conclusion
Twilight>HP = Stupid
HP<Twilight = educated people who have half a brain and don't support domestic violence.
I rest my case
I personally really enjoyed both series. Twilight is a definite love story, and it does take on an obsessive note with Bella and Edward. But I still found myself lost in the characters. I think it did take a fair amount of imagination to create and it was a very enjoyable read. It didn’t require any real thought and just allowed me to have my escape from reality. And with twilight, i am strictly talking about the books. Harry potter is a more complex story line, that is undeniable. I waited up till midnight on release dates and spent months/years anticipating the next installment. I come across these arguments regularly, which is better? In my personal opinion, they both have their merits. Stop arguing and just peacefully allow others to enjoy whatever literature that speaks to them. Because at the end of the day, isn’t that what books are all about?
I’m not a fan of Harry Potter or Twilight, but I can say that Harry Potter is better. The only part of the Twilight franchise I’ve enjoyed would have to be the graphic novel I read for class. That, at least, didn’t have 500 pages of useless details; in fact it seemed to have more of a plot than all four of the “novels” put together.
Harry Potter, on the other hand, keeps you engaged. I saw the first and fourth films and loved them. I didn’t even have to watch the trailers for Twilight to know the films would be bigger garbage than the books. I still don’t know what SM was smoking, but I’m pretty sure it was meth, or it could have been cocaine…that’s the only way she could have come up with a “vampire” that glitters like a jewel and whines about having to drink blood. And don’t even get me started on Bella, or Jacob, or any of the others.
Harry Potter has and always will kick Twilight’s drugged ass.
Nicole while i appreciate what you were going for I’m unsure if you understand the what the > is used for, that which is greater needs to be on the open side. For you equation to work the second needs to read HP>Twilight = educated people who have half a brain and don’t support domestic violence; other wise your educated people would actually like Twilight and we know that’s not the case.
http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/archive/ldn/1950/71/5071508
You all are Harry Potter Fans defending Harry from Twillight. But now another problem takes a toll, Christians are totally bashing Harry. Can’t Christians just accept the fact that Harry is pure fiction and that not everyone is ‘holy’ and does ‘righteous things’. Don’t they make mistakes too?
Oh and Twillight is probably bashed to pieces now. Bash it anymore and it’ll be dust.
-Pro Harry Potter Anti Twilight Fan
Not all Christians hate Harry Potter. Personally, I don’t see anything wrong with it. I adore Harry Potter, it’s freaking amazing! I’m a Christian, too. My brother is actually the youth leader at our church and he loves it to. He and his wife took me to the Wizarding World of Harry Potter for my birthday this summer. At the church Halloween party, I went as Harry Potter. I’ve worn HP t-shirts to church. I just realized how many examples I gave. Okay, I’ll go now. Not ALL Christians are against Harry Potter
wow i just love the that twilight really has nothing against THE MOST AWESOME AND BEST BOOK SLASH MOVIE EVER tell me if you guys like the fact 2
you know the voltori arent really bad guys there just mean and eat what a normal vamp would eat for food just saying and there not very realistic villans again just saying
@Eileen: Yes I know some stricter Christians do bash Harry Potter, if you look at any religion there are always extremes. I am a Christian and on fire for God, but I absolutely love Harry Potter. So you never know.
HP is beter. i read the saga 2 times and im reading it agen. i read twigh light saga once tried to read it agen but it bord me hafe to death
Let’s make the following thing clear:
-The Twilight plot can be told in 5 sentences or less.
-The Harry Potter plot can be told in 200+ sentences.
Comparing Twilight to Harry Potter is like comparing Robert Gober to Leonardo Da Vinci. I’m not sure why there’s people who actually think there’s deepness or hidden beauty in Twilight; it’s actually about a teenage girl falling in love with a oh-so-handsome godly perfect vampire.
One more thing: Vampires don’t sparkle in sunlight; they DIE.
Meyer has done terrible things to vampires and werewolfs.
HP definitely has better depths, some actually entertaining fictional history, that really solidifies the fictional world, and excellent morals and messages to be learned and experienced.
Twilight is basically another romantic tale, except made more interesting by adding fictional concepts like HP. It hardly has the depth, morale or history of its own fictional world than that of HP world.
HP novels are fantastic. Twilight novels are nice in their own rights. HP movies sorta go downhill after Prisoner of Azkaban. They way they left plot holes and added unneeded scenes after the 3rd film is just unforgiving. The only truly faithful HP film is ‘Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets’.
I believe all of Twilight films to be far more faithful to its books than HP ones. Excuse me, I’m a purist.
In the end, Twilight is something that you’d watch with your girlfriend. HP is something you can watch with your friends AND your girlfriend.
Sorry it took me so long to reply. I was too busy chillin at OUR themepark.
But, no worries, twilight could have an amusment park too…
there could be a rollar coaster of bella’s emotions!
Or a snackbar filled with blood!
HPFOREVER<3
okay two things, does annyone realise the lowest earning harry potter movie earned more than the highest earning twilight movie also jo is a MILLIONARE, look it up in the guiness book of world records jo s the richest author in the WORLD! right okay if you were in a teenage girl gym class maybe u could say there would bemore twilght fans in that room but worldwide there is just no competetion. of all the girls in my class there is aactully only one that doesn’t like twilight because of the actors, half of them haven’t even read the books. WE HAVE A THEM PARK. MUGGLE QUIDDTCH IS NOW AN OFFICAL INTERNATIONAL SPORT.
People who say harry potter has no depth are making it up. There are two parts of harry potter the kiddies magical part and the other deep meaning of love, which only mature people can see. I being only eleven I can see it, evenn if you twilight fans can’t, then again you are the people that you think the world is perfect and bella is this Beautifull, intelligent woan who happens two have two guys chasing after her, A sparkilng vampire and a Dog/wearwolve. I enjoy both parts of harry potter. Let me tell you though the world isn’t perfect, nobody’s perfect, Jo should that sometimes Harry is anry, Sometimes Hermione is a litle OTT with nerdiness and sometimes Ron is very tactless but stephanie meyer (did i spell her name right?) has conjured up this alternate universe where everything was perfect and a more Beautifull, intelligent version had two guys running after her then she enleashed this terrible sin into the world where it has taken the form of Twilight, this was sm’s dream don’t let it become yours.
right okay if you right a book you can base a character on yourself. but stephanie meyers alternate her was perfect, beautifull and intelligent. she even named her ISABELLA SWAN does any one get that IS | A | BELLA | SWAN and bella means beautifull so really she is saying bella IS | A | BEAUTIFULL | SWAN. Really stephanie meyer beleives herself to be a beautifull swan with oh so perfect guys demanding she be theirs, time for a reality check i think.
twilight is for socially awkward losers who have failed so much in their own love life, that they are forced to read the most $h!t filled love storry ever.
Harry potter is for socially awyward losers that will read the books so many times that when they look at twigs and other normal items they see wants and magical items.
Both stories are fictional! Ya’ll need to sort yo effing priorities. Your gonna sit on Bits of Wisdom all day fighting like a bunch of little kids? Wow. have a nice life.
Well … I’m guessing you don’t like Harry Potter OR Twilight, huh?
Then why did you choose to come on to this site? The title clearly implies that this is a debate.
As a Harry Potter fan I have no idea why I’m even bothering to compare Harry Potter to the utterly horrendous thing that is known as Twilight. But I am. Twilight was by far the most boring, plot lacking, poorly written book I’ve ever read. Therefore, a story about a teenage wizard facing off against a dark lord named Voldemort beats one about a stupid little love sick slut named Bella anyday
To the Twerds/Twihards/Crap Lovers
Avada Kedavra B****es